Sci-Fi Diner OR 50's Prime Time Cafe?

[steamboat willy]

We are flip flopping between Sci-Fi and 50's Prime Time Cafe before viewing Fantasmic that night. We have found (2) different menus on (2) different sites sites and was wondering which is more up to date. We like the one we found here on INTERCOT the best (more selections at Sci-Fi) and was wondering if anyone knows how acurate the menus actually are.
OR, if you had to choose between the two for other reasons...What would that be?
Sci-Fi or 50's Prime Time

[japhilli]

I would say the food is better at 50's PrimeTime, but the theming of SciFi is great. My son loves to go there....so we go every year. I have found most posted menus to be pretty accurate.

We think SciFi is more fun.


Love the pot roast at PrimeTime

Love the reuben at SciFi

[Hayden's Dad]

Sci Fi is a must for us on all of our trips. You can't beat the themeing.

[ibelieveindisneymagic]

I would choose Prime Time. The theming at Sci-Fi is neat, but the food is just horrible, it was the worst we've ever had at Disney.

Prime Time can be really fun, if you get a good server. Even if you don't, at least the food is good!

[yjgirl32]

We are trying both this Sept. I was told that going to Sci-Fi we should stick to like appetizers & burgers. Oh and to get a milkshake. Good luck in your decision.

[WishingStar2006]

I would go with 50's Prime Time too...while Sci-Fi is a neat experience, the food is very sub-par. I would make an ADR for Sci-Fi but only get a milk shake to enjoy the ambiance and then go to 50's Prime TIme to eat. The food is much better and if you get a good server, the experience is a real hoot!

[EmmMOM2]

For us Prime time can tend to get annoying depending on which waitress/waiter you receive. One lady was a little too overbearing.
I don't like feeling pressure about eating everything on my plate when trying something new.
I'd go for Sci-Fi even though the food is sub par.

[lightyearfan]

well maybe i'm in the monority here, but me and dw have never had a problem with food at the sci-fi, and we will be going back again this upcoming trip, 50's is also a place that we've been too a few times and it too is very good, it's like the other posts before me said the theming is much better at sci-fi and there tends to be more of a home feel to the prime time, no matter which one you choose you won't be disappointed (IMHO)

enjoy your trip
Victor

[andreallybadeggs]

Agree with last poster. It never ceases to amaze me how different people feel about the food at various WDW restaurants but Sci Fi is pretty polarizing. My family absolutely loves it there.
Wouldn't go so far as to say the food is the best we had in the world but we've never been dissatisfied no matter what time of day.
50's food is pretty good (not great in my opinion) and it can be a lot of fun but only if your group gets into the spirit and your server is feeling the role as well.
I've gotten the same "cousin" the last three times.
First time was great, second time was OK, third time she was crabby and borderline rude to our guests who were not very hungry (and on a limited budget) so asked to share a meal. I've NEVER experienced that anywhere else at WDW and was really embarrassed by the whole scene.

[EpcotFan182]

I would choose the 50's Prime Time.

The theming for the Sci-Fi is cool, but I didn't think the food was as good. Plus you can have a lot of fun at 50's.

[Disney Doll]

I've never been to 50's prime time, but here's my on Sci Fi. I know it gets pretty unfavorable reviews a lot of times, but I don't think it's that bad. It's not a gourmet dining establishment, it's a drive in diner. That being said I would stick to ordering things you would expect to find at a drive in diner...burgers, onion rings, shakes, etc. I notice they have other things on the menu, but I would not order ribs or pasta at the drive in and expect it to be good. The atmosphere is a lot of fun and I would recommend that everyone try it at least once.

[DisneyFr33k]

I would choose Prime Time. The theming at Sci-Fi is neat, but the food is just horrible, it was the worst we've ever had at Disney.

Prime Time can be really fun, if you get a good server. Even if you don't, at least the food is good!

I agree 100%. We ate at sci fi once, had to wait an insanely long time to be seated (we had ADR's), the movie clips were hokie and repeated several times during our dinner (you would think they would run some that didn't repeat for at least an hour), and the food portions were small and the quality poor.

50's Prime Time - food is really good, service is fun! You can't go wrong there.

[joonyer]

Actually, we have found the food at Sci-Fi Dine in to be really good, . . . if you stick with the typical lunch menu items. I highly recommend their Burgers, reuben sandwiches, onion rings (some of the best I've ever had) and the milkshakes.

I would stay away from the dinner entrees, though, they are usually not as good as the burgers and sandwiches. Treat it as a "drive-in" and stick to "drive-in" menu items and you'll enjoy the food there.

[Madzac]

We are another family that just LOVED the Sci Fi. That is one place my kids have reuqested to go back to again. We had wonderful food... though we stuck to the burgers and fries and they were awesome!

i have been to 50's as well though it has been a few trips. It was ok. The theming was a little too in your face for me. But lots of people like it, and there is more variety to the menu. Its not a must do for me.

If I was looking for a great lunch and fun for young kids, I would do sci fi. If I wanted a more substatial dinner in a place where you are "part of the show", I would chose 50's PT.

[Tink-N-Me]

I would difinitely pick the Prime Time over the Sci-Fi. For me Disney is all about the experience and the servers at the Prime Time can really put on a show (live interactive entertainment) as compared to old black & white short movies, that don't hold my kids attention. Also, my kids love to pick out their dessert through the old time toy view finders at the 50's.

[VolMickey]

I was wondering this myself, thanks everyone for posting!

[Jeffybob]

PRIMETIME ... just keep you elbows off the table or you will be singing "I'm a little tea pot" for the dining room!

[maxrebo77]

SciFi
About 45 minutes before your ADR, head over to 50's. Have a nice cocktail at the Tune In lounge and watch some of the old TVs. When you get to SciFi, enjoy the experience. Order what you would expect to eat in that setting. It will never be fine dining, but for me a lot of fun. I love the old film clips, and there are some Hidden Mickey's there too. And glow cubes!

[Lizzy]

It has been years since I have been to either, but I would say 50s over Sci-fi.

I was glad that I did try Sci-fi and for lunch it was not too bad, but the food at 50s was way better. I have eaten at 50s a couple times now and enjoyed it every time.

[queenstorm24]

During our last trip we went to Sci-Fi. It was ok. We will be trying 50's Prime Time for this visit.