Ice Cream - What's your favorite?

[Ed]

Other than the obvious , Blue Bunny Peanut Butter Panic!

[RedSoxFan]

Chocolate is my favorite. I'm not a huge ice cream fan. My other favorite is Ben & Jerry's Gerry Garcia.

[Flower]

I was ticked that WDW is no longer selling the Toll House Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich I was SO looking forward to one during our past trip

[Marker]

Vanilla. Call me boring, but I like vanilla. Sure, I'll eat other flavors, but vanilla is the one I always come back too.

[wdwgrl377]

I love Blue Bell Chocolate Chip, but they don't sell it here in NC, that I know of. I sure do miss that ice cream.

I do like Breyer's Natural Vanilla, with chocolate syrup, and I like Chocolate Almond, from Baskin Robbins!!

[quest4dl]

We have a wonderful mom and pop ice cream shop in the burbs of Chicago called Capanari's. They make the most delicious ice cream I have ever tasted. For commercial brands I like Haagen Daz - current favourite flavour is Caramelized Pear and Toasted Pecan.

[Jeff G]

Ben & Jerry's Phish Food

(Brett, thanks for mentioning Baskin Robbin's Rocky Road. That's a close 2nd and I already have a plan laid out for tonight to got have ice cream with the family)

[laprana]

My absolute all time favorite is Baskin Robins Mint Chocolate Chip! A close second is Edys Rocky Road with the whole mini marshmallows!

[Dakota Rose]

Mudpie Mojo at Coldstone Creamery

or

Chocolate Macadamia Nut at Lappert's

or

good old fashioned chocolate from the grocery store.

[Shugoondola]

I'm not too adventurous, but my favorites are vanilla and chocolate. Favorite brand is Blue Bell.

[Tink&Goofy]

Chocolate....doesn't matter what brand, or what is mixed in it (but an extra bonus for something chocolate mixed in . Chocolate....why waste the calories on any other flavor???

[The Reservoir Dog]

Mmmmmm Ice Cream!!!!

As someone else mention it depends on mood but my faves include Mint Choc, Cookies & Cream, that Cherry Garcia one and good old plain Chocolate flavour.

However at a friends house once he served up some Lemon ice cream and it was absolutely delicious.

[MissStyles]

has anyone seen the foodnetwork special "scoop" that aired a couple years ago? the winning flavor sticky toffee pudding is amazing. it's put out by haagen dazs. it's AWESOME! sunday i tried one of the runner up flavors...toasted coconut sesame brittle and it's also fantastic. haagen dazs is such a sin i only allow myself a few spoonfuls at a time.....but i love it just the same!

i love ice cream - i eat it nearly every single day. it's my one treat that i can't live without!

[Dracula766]

I agree with Emily. Haagen Dazs Sticky Toffee Pudding is the best!

The Coconut Pineapple is pretty good too. I had to steal my mom's pint.

[SBETigg]

Northampton MA's Herrell's Malted Vanilla with smooshed in Chocolate Malt Balls.

But close: Haagen Dazs Vanilla, Ben & Jerry's Cherry Garcia, Ben & Jerry's Chunky Monkey, and Ben & Jerry's White Russian topped them all but it was discontinued.

[BelleLovesTheBeast]

Cinnamoo from Maggie Moo's
Cherry Garcia from Ben and Jerry's

but my absolute favorite is Jamoca from Baskin Robbins. Has been for years.

[mjstaceyuofm]

My wife got an ice cream maker about 5 years back and I'm quite surprised at how much we use it. From her machine, I have a few faves:

1) Strawberry
2) Bailey's Irish Cream

But by far, my favorite is plain old CHOCOLATE from Krogers (Private Selection is the brand) with a heaping spoonful of JIF peanut butter slathered on top.

Yum.

[scottgr]

YUMMMM ICE CREAM....
Cold Stone ---- Coffee and snickers...
YUMMM

[Jared]

I firmly believe Haagen-Dazs makes the best ice cream in the world, even better than most homemade places, especially coffee and chocolate chocolate chip.

[ljv1975]

I love mint chocolate chip - I would like it even more if I could find some that was only the mint with NO chips!

Ben & Jerry's - Creme Brulee and Half Baked

During the Holidays, they make the peppermint kind which I also enjoy.

I can't pick just one!!