If I lived close enough, I'd go over and test the 1 day experience. Roll up in the morning at rope drop and only use the in-park kiosks for FP+. That would be the real test of what their experience is like. Maybe it is better than I imagine or have been led to believe from others.

A 30 minute FP+ wait for PotC is incredible. I don't know if I ever waited that long in standby for that ride, even right in the middle of the summer.