So we were at WDW last week on free dining. We had an ADR at Les Chefs de France for lunch. I had gotten a bad cold during our trip and on this day I felt particularly bad so I really wasn't hungry. DH and I both order off of the prix fixe menu soup, entree, dessert. I ate some of my soup and couldn't really eat the entree so when the waiter came around for dessert I told him I just wanted to skip it because I wasn't hungry. DH had his dessert. When we got the bill instead of just 1 tableservice credit each, he also charged me for the soup! I asked him why and because I did not have dessert he changed it to an ala carte purchase. I know it was said no substitutions, but I didn't substitute - I was just trying to not waste food! DH wouldn't let me argue the cost because he said the waiter seemed new and not very good with English.

What are your thoughts - should i have been charged for the soup or no?

Thanks!
Kari